Premium Marketplace Curation
Share
A deep dive into how curated marketplaces succeed by focusing on high-value items and professional presentation, particularly looking at examples like Bring A Trailer and Cars & Bids.
Key Elements of Successful Curated Marketplaces
- Focus on specific niches with passionate communities
- Professional presentation and documentation
- Build trust through curation and quality control
- Enable high-value transactions ($30k-$1M+)
Notable Examples
Bring A Trailer
- Started as a simple WordPress blog
- Sold $1.2B worth of cars in trailing 12 months
- Generated ~$100M in net revenue
- Operates with only 80 employees
- Focuses on car enthusiasts interested in 70s-90s vehicles
Cars & Bids (Doug DeMuro)
- Similar model to Bring A Trailer
- Founded by popular YouTube car reviewer
- Predicted to be a potential multi-hundred million dollar exit
- Built on founder's credibility and existing audience
Why Curated Marketplaces Work
- Solves the "eBay problem" of overwhelming options
- Creates a "delightful auction" experience
- Professional photography increases value
- Example: Airbnb sent photographers to premium listings
- Better photos could increase nightly rates ($1000 → $1500)
Potential New Categories for Curated Marketplaces
- Homes
- Watches (like Hodinkee)
- Livestock
- High-value transactions ($50k+ for premium animals)
- Cash-heavy business
- Built-in passionate community
- Golf equipment
- Enthusiast market
- Knowledge gap creates opportunity
- Lifetime customer value ~$10k+
Success Factors
- Community takes ownership once established
- Platform becomes facilitator rather than controller
- Beautiful documentation and presentation
- Focus on premium, high-ticket items
- Strong editorial voice and curation
Sam Parr
Host of MFM and fitness influencer
Sam Parr is a serial entrepreneur and business media pioneer.
In 2016, he founded The Hustle, a business news media company that started in his kitchen with just $12 and grew to eight figures in revenue.
Sam led the charge in making newsletters popular when few believed in their potential.
After four successful years, he sold The Hustle to HubSpot, a publicly traded company. Now operating as HubSpot Media, The Hustle reaches 3 million readers daily, employs a team of nearly 100, and has been the launchpad for dozens of its staff to found their own media companies and newsletters.
Sam remains the host of the popular business podcast, My First Million, and continues to start and sell companies. He also co-founded Hampton, a highly vetted community for entrepreneurs, founders, and CEOs, and teaches people to write better through his platform, Copy That.